Nabatmama v. Ross Morgan & Co., Inc.

Summary by

Share this article

Pejman D. Kharrazian, Esq.
Shareholder

Emily A. Long, Esq.
Coachella Valley Office Manager

Nabatmama v. Ross Morgan & Co., Inc.

(2025) U.S. Dist. LEXIS 69135

Key Facts:

  • The association imposed over $106,000 in fines against a tenant for alleged violations of its CC&Rs.
  • The association’s management company began efforts to collect the fines.
  • The tenant sued the management company under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA); who responds by filing a motion to dismiss the case.

Holding: 

  • The court drew a distinction between assessments and fines.
  • Fines are not considered a “debt” under the FDCPA.
  • Fines are penalties imposed for violations and not from the agreement to pay regular assessments.

Takeaways:

  • Regular assessments arise under a consensual transaction tied to a purchase of property, while fines are penalties for rule violations.

    For this reason, community association assessments are considered debts and subject to the FDCPA, but fines are not.